All Currently released smiling/nightmare critter plushies Alignment Chart

all of the currently available ones in the official webstore. Icky Licky, Touille and Rabie Baby plushies have yet to be released as I'm writing this. Edit: they've been released!! I've added them onto the list^^ [last edited: december 23rd 2025]

Create a All Currently released smiling/nightmare critter plushies alignment chart. Check out our other Toys tier list templates and the most recent user submitted Toys tier lists.

Template last modified: 12/23/2025

Create a Meme 🔴 Live Voting Poll  Tier List View  View Community Rank

Add additional images to your tier list. Images are not saved to the website, but will be included in your download.

Log in to save your Tier List to your profile.
Download Image

No preview image? Regenerate now

X

View the Community Ranking for this All Currently released smiling/nightmare critter plushies Tier List & recent user lists

Credit to https://poppyplaytime.com/ for the images.